Tag Archives: shooters

Prosecutors say school shooter’s father was ‘grossly negligent,’ while defense says his manslaughter case is built on ‘hindsight’ – CNN

  1. Prosecutors say school shooter’s father was ‘grossly negligent,’ while defense says his manslaughter case is built on ‘hindsight’ CNN
  2. Prosecutor urges jury to convict Michigan school shooter’s dad, says he could have prevented tragedy Fox News
  3. Why we may never know where murder weapon was in days before Oxford shooting WDIV ClickOnDetroit
  4. James Crumbley Declines to Testify in Oxford High School Shooting Trial The New York Times
  5. Prosecutor urges jury to convict Michigan school shooter’s dad as both sides rest KOMO News

Read original article here

Uvalde shooter’s cousin is arrested over making a school shooting threat, court records say – The Associated Press

  1. Uvalde shooter’s cousin is arrested over making a school shooting threat, court records say The Associated Press
  2. Cousin of Uvalde shooter arrested after allegedly threatening to ‘do the same thing’ Los Angeles Times
  3. Teenage cousin of Uvalde school shooter is arrested, accused of threatening to ‘do the same thing’ to a school CNN
  4. Reports: Cousin of Uvalde gunman arrested after threatening San Antonio school KXAN.com
  5. Teen related to Uvalde shooter accused of plotting to carry out similar attack, Texas police say KENS 5: Your San Antonio News Source
  6. View Full Coverage on Google News

Read original article here

Expert details Pittsburgh synagogue shooter’s troubled childhood ‘laden with trauma’ – TribLIVE

  1. Expert details Pittsburgh synagogue shooter’s troubled childhood ‘laden with trauma’ TribLIVE
  2. Synagogue gunman had traumatic childhood and couldn’t function as an adult, defense expert testifies The Associated Press
  3. Jurors weigh death penalty or life in prison for Pittsburgh synagogue killer PBS NewsHour
  4. Court releases family photos of Pittsburgh synagogue shooting victims TribLIVE
  5. ‘No one asked for this’: Relatives of the 11 synagogue shooting victims relive the pain that still haunts them Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
  6. View Full Coverage on Google News

Read original article here

Judge denies Oxford shooter’s attempt to avoid life without parole – Detroit News

  1. Judge denies Oxford shooter’s attempt to avoid life without parole Detroit News
  2. Judge to Oxford school shooter Ethan Crumbley: Life without parole still on the table Yahoo! Voices
  3. Judge denies Oxford shooter’s request to dismiss life without parole condition Click On Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV
  4. Ethan Crumbley’s request for removing life sentence without possibility of parole denied by judge FOX 2 Detroit
  5. Judge denies Oxford shooter’s request to dismiss life without parole condition, wear street clothes WDIV ClickOnDetroit
  6. View Full Coverage on Google News

Read original article here

Nashville manifesto: Christian school shooter’s parents seek possession of trans killer’s writings – Fox News

  1. Nashville manifesto: Christian school shooter’s parents seek possession of trans killer’s writings Fox News
  2. Attorney: Ownership of Nashville shooter’s writing will go to students’ parents WBIR Channel 10
  3. Nashville shooter Audrey Hale’s parents transfer manifesto to Covenant School parents — who are battling to keep it from being released New York Post
  4. Attorney: Ownership of Nashville shooter’s writing will go to students’ parents WBIR.com
  5. School Shooter’s Parents Will Hand Ownership of Writings to Victims The New York Times
  6. View Full Coverage on Google News

Read original article here

Nashville Parents Can Have Say in Case Over Shooter’s Writings, Judge Rules – The New York Times

  1. Nashville Parents Can Have Say in Case Over Shooter’s Writings, Judge Rules The New York Times
  2. Judge rules parents of students killed and traumatized in Nashville mass shooting to have say in release of evidence ABC News
  3. Judge rules Covenant parents can intervene in hearing on release of shooter’s writings WZTV
  4. Judge rules on Covenant School, church & parents’ involvement in debate over releasing shooter’s writings WKRN News 2
  5. Expert: Involving families in Covenant writings debate could set precedent WKRN News 2
  6. View Full Coverage on Google News

Read original article here

Journals and guns: What police found inside The Covenant School shooter’s home – News Channel 5 Nashville

  1. Journals and guns: What police found inside The Covenant School shooter’s home News Channel 5 Nashville
  2. Nashville police find suicide note, yearbooks, weapons, ammo at school shooter Audrey Hale’s home: report Fox News
  3. Detectives in Nashville say the shooter, a former student, spent months planning the attack KENS 5: Your San Antonio News Source
  4. Search warrants for Covenant School shooter reveal shotguns, journals describing shootings WZTV
  5. Nashville police: School shooter planned attack for months Boston News, Weather, Sports | WHDH 7News
  6. View Full Coverage on Google News

Read original article here

Colorado shooter’s 2021 case dropped for lack of cooperation

COLORADO SPRINGS, Colo. (AP) — The Colorado Springs gay nightclub shooter had charges dropped in a 2021 bomb threat case after family members who were terrorized in the incident refused to cooperate, according to the district attorney and court documents unsealed Thursday.

The charges were dropped despite authorities finding a “tub” full of bomb-making chemicals and later receiving warnings from other relatives that suspect Anderson Lee Aldrich was sure to hurt or murder a set of grandparents if freed, according to the unsealed documents.

In a letter last November to state District Court Judge Robin Chittum, the relatives painted a picture of an isolated, violent person who did not have a job and was given $30,000 that was spent largely on the purchase of 3D printers to make guns.

Aldrich tried to reclaim guns that were seized after the threat, but authorities did not return the weapons, El Paso County District Attorney Michael Allen said.

Allen spoke hours after Chittum unsealed the case, which included allegations that Aldrich threatened to kill the grandparents and to become the “next mass killer” more than a year before the nightclub attack that killed five people.

The suspect’s mother and the grandparents derailed that earlier case by evading prosecutors’ efforts to serve them with a subpoena, leading to a dismissal of the charges after defense attorneys said speedy trial rules were at risk, Allen said.

Testifying at a hearing two months after the threat, the suspect’s mother and grandmother described Aldrich in court as a “loving” and “sweet” young person who did not deserve to be jailed, the prosecutor said.

The former district attorney who was replaced by Allen told The Associated Press he faced many cases in which people dodged subpoenas, but the inability to serve Aldrich’s family seemed extraordinary.

“I don’t know that they were hiding, but if that was the case, shame on them,” Dan May said of the suspect’s family. “This is an extreme example of apparent manipulation that has resulted in something horrible.”

Aldrich’s attorney, public defender Joseph Archambault, had argued against the document release, saying Aldrich’s right to a fair trial was paramount.

“This will make sure there is no presumption of innocence,” Archambault said.

The grandmother’s in-laws wrote to the court in November 2021 saying that Alrich was a continuing danger and should remain incarcerated. The letter also said police tried to hold Aldrich for 72 hours after a prior response to the home, but the grandmother intervened.

“We believe that my brother, and his wife, would undergo bodily harm or more if Anderson were released. Besides being incarcerated, we believe Anderson needs therapy and counseling,” Robert Pullen and Jeanie Streltzoff wrote. They said Aldrich had punched holes in the walls of the grandparents’ Colorado home and broken windows and that the grandparents “had to sleep in their bedroom with the door locked” and a bat by the bed.

During Aldrich’s teenage years in San Antonio, the letter said, Aldrich attacked the grandfather and sent him to the emergency room with undisclosed injuries. The grandfather later lied to police out of fear of Aldrich, according to the letter, which said the suspect could not get along with classmates as a youth so had been homeschooled.

The judge’s order comes after news organizations, including the AP, sought to unseal the documents, and two days after AP published portions of the documents that were verified with a law enforcement official.

Aldrich, 22, was arrested in June 2021 on allegations of making a threat that led to the evacuation of about 10 homes. The documents describe how Aldrich told the frightened grandparents about firearms and bomb-making material in the grandparents’ basement and vowed not to let them interfere with plans for Aldrich to be “the next mass killer” and “go out in a blaze.”

Aldrich — who uses they/them pronouns and is nonbinary, according to their attorneys — holed up in their mother’s home in a standoff with SWAT teams and warned about having armor-piercing rounds and a determination to “go to the end.” Investigators later searched the mother’s and grandparents’ houses where they found and seized handguns, hundreds of rounds of ammunition, body armor, magazines, a gas mask and a tub filled with chemicals that make an explosive when combined, documents show.

A sheriff’s report said there had been prior calls to law enforcement referring to Aldrich’s “escalating homicidal behavior” but did not elaborate. A sheriff’s office spokesperson did not immediately provide more information.

The grandparents’ call to 911 led to the suspect’s arrest, and Aldrich was booked into jail on suspicion of felony menacing and kidnapping. But after Aldrich’s bond was set at $1 million, Aldrich’s mother and grandparents sought to lower the bond, which was reduced to $100,000 with conditions including therapy.

The case was dropped when attempts to serve the family members with subpoenas to testify against Aldrich failed, according to Allen. Both grandparents moved out of state, complicating the subpoena process, Allen said.

Grandmother Pamela Pullen said through an attorney that there was a subpoena in her mailbox, but it was never handed to her personally or served properly, documents show.

“At the end of the day, they weren’t going to testify against Andy,” Xavier Kraus, a former friend and neighbor of Aldrich, told AP.

Kraus said he had text messages from Aldrich’s mother saying that she and the suspect were “hiding from somebody.” He later found out the family had been dodging subpoenas. Aldrich’s “words were, ‘They got nothing. There’s no evidence,’” Kraus said.

A protective order against the suspect that was in place until July 5 prevented Aldrich from possessing firearms, the El Paso County Sheriff’s Office said.

Soon after the charges were dropped, Aldrich began boasting that they had regained access to firearms, Kraus said, adding that Aldrich had shown him two assault-style rifles, body armor and incendiary rounds.

Aldrich “was really excited about it,” Kraus said, and slept with a rifle nearby under a blanket.

Relatives of Aldrich’s grandmother said after the suspect’s 2021 arrest that she had recently given Aldrich $30,000, “much of which went to his purchase of two 3D printers — on which he was making guns,” according to documents in the case.

Aldrich’s statements in the bomb case raised questions about whether authorities could have used Colorado’s “red flag” law to seize weapons from the suspect.

El Paso County Sheriff Bill Elder released a statement Thursday saying that there was no need to ask for a red flag order because Aldrich’s weapons had already been seized as part of the arrest and Aldrich couldn’t buy new ones.

The sheriff also rejected the idea that he could have asked for a red flag order after the case was dismissed. The bombing case was too old to argue there was danger in the near future, Elder said, and the evidence was sealed a month after the dismissal and couldn’t be used.

“There was no legal mechanism” to take guns following the case dismissal, the sheriff said.

Under Colorado law, records are automatically sealed when a case is dropped and defendants are not prosecuted, as happened in Aldrich’s 2021 case. Once sealed, officials cannot acknowledge that the records exist, and the process to unseal the documents initially happens behind closed doors with no docket to follow and an unnamed judge.

Chittum said the “profound” public interest in the case outweighed Aldrich’s privacy rights. The judge added that scrutiny of judicial cases is “foundational to our system of government.”

During Thursday’s hearing, Aldrich sat at the defense table looking straight ahead or down at times and did not appear to show any reaction when their mother’s lawyer asked that the case remain sealed.

Aldrich was formally charged Tuesday with 305 criminal counts, including hate crimes and murder, in the Nov. 19 shooting at Club Q, a sanctuary for the LGBTQ community in mostly conservative Colorado Springs.

Investigators say Aldrich entered just before midnight with an AR-15-style semiautomatic rifle and began shooting during a drag queen’s birthday celebration. Patrons stopped the killing by wrestling the suspect to the ground and beating Aldrich into submission, witnesses said.

Seventeen people suffered gunshot wounds but survived, authorities said.

___

Mustian, Balsamo and Condon reported from New York, and Bedayn reported from Denver. Matthew Brown in Billings, Montana, contributed to this report. Bedayn is a corps member for The Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.

Read original article here

Zach Cruz, Florida school shooter’s brother, robbed of inheritance, police say

Zach Cruz left Florida after the 2018 massacre. Now the men who gave him a home in Virginia are accused of stealing his inheritance.

Zach Cruz, center, is the brother of Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz, top left. Zach was taken in by Richard Moore, top right, and Mike Donovan, bottom right, who are now charged with stealing his inheritance money. (Julia Rendleman/For The Washington Post)(Amy Beth Bennett/South Florida Sun Sentinel via AP, Pool)(Norm Shafer/ For The Washington Post).

Comment

By the time the jury filed back into the Florida courtroom, its benches were full. Here were the families, whose sons and daughters and spouses had been slaughtered. Here were the attorneys, who had asked survivors to testify about the day their limbs, their entire lives had been irrevocably maimed. Here were the sheriff’s deputies, the judge, all the people who had come to court day after day, week after week, waiting for this moment, when they would finally learn what was going to happen to Nikolas Cruz.

But when the Parkland school shooter looked up, there was one person he did not see.

Zachary Cruz, 22, was the only close family member he had left. When Cruz went on a killing rampage at his former high school, it was Zach, then 17, who agonized over whether he could have done something to prevent it. When Cruz was arrested, it was Zach who went into the interrogation room to demand, “Why did you do this?” When Cruz started to sob, it was Zach who wrapped his older brother in his arms.

“I’m gonna come to your trial. I’ll come to everything,” Zach promised his brother, who he always calls Nik, a transcript of the 2018 conversation shows. “I swear on everything I love, I will come see you every chance I’m given. All right? No matter what happens.”

Four and a half years later, Zach hadn’t been to Florida in months. He rarely held online video visits with his brother. And despite being the most highly anticipated witness in the death penalty trial, Zach never came to testify.

Zachary Cruz visited his older brother, Nikolas Cruz, at the Broward Sheriff’s Office Parkland, Fla., in 2018. (Video: Whitney Leaming/TWP)

“His brother loves him,” the shooter’s public defender had assured the jury during her closing statement.

The prosecutor objected. “Not in evidence,” he said.

To the defense team, Zach not taking the stand was a lost opportunity to show what the Cruz brothers had endured growing up. To the prosecutors, it was a missed chance to cross-examine the person who may have best understood the mental state of one of the nation’s deadliest school shooters.

His brother confessed to gunning down 17 people in Parkland. But he’s the only family Zach Cruz has left.

But Zach’s absence was also noticeable to investigators far from Florida, who saw it as another sign of what they had suspected for more than a year: Zachary Cruz was in trouble.

On Oct. 5, one week before the verdict, police raided the house where Zach lives in Virginia. Zach was photographed sitting outside the house, surrounded by Augusta County sheriff’s deputies. But they weren’t there to arrest him. They said he was a victim of a crime.

The alleged perpetrators were Richard Moore and Mike Donovan, both 45, the Virginia entrepreneurs who offered to take Zach in shortly after the shooting. In depositions and previous interviews, Zach has called the couple his guardians, saying they gave him a home, a family and a place to do the one thing he loved, skateboarding.

But police and court records allege that Moore and Donovan, who were already being prosecuted by state and federal agencies for their business practices, stole the money Zach inherited from his late mother’s estate — more than $400,000 — to pay taxes, bills and car payments on their Ferrari.

During the raid of the couple’s home and business headquarters, police collected more than 90 phones, computers and other devices as potential evidence. Moore and Donovan were charged with obtaining money by false pretenses and exploiting someone who is mentally incapacitated. They were released from jail on $50,000 bonds.

The men have called the charges “bogus.” They contend Zach is being victimized not by them, but by the Augusta County Sheriff’s department, accusing its deputies of handcuffing and holding Zach at gunpoint during the raid.

“We love Zach, and we would never exploit him,” Donovan wrote in an email to The Washington Post, saying Zach has “always had 100% control over what happened to his money.”

The arrests of Moore and Donovan came more than a year after a Virginia social services agency began to question whether Zach, who had no other family looking out for him, was being taken advantage of.

Parkland families unleash anger at gunman, justice system after painful trial

Though Zach is an adult and Moore and Donovan have no legal guardianship over him, he has become entangled in the complex web that surrounds the couple — one involving dozens of lawsuits, a myriad of spinoff businesses, an FBI investigation and a contentious public battle with reality TV star Dog the Bounty Hunter.

On the day of the verdict in Florida, the jury delivered a decisive outcome for Nikolas Cruz: Instead of being executed, he will spend the rest of his life in prison.

But for Zach, the future is much less certain. He never finished high school and does not have a job. If convicted, the men who took him in could go to prison. Moore is facing even more prison time in separate cases involving perjury and tax fraud. And according to police records, Zach’s inheritance money is gone.

After a Post reporter spoke to Zach for this story in September, Zach’s phone number was changed. Additional attempts to interview him in person were unsuccessful.

Moore and Donovan, who are expected to plead not guilty to the charges against them, continue to post photos of Zach on social media. Following their initial appearance in the case, they shared a photo of their family standing outside the Augusta County courthouse.

Zach’s arm was wrapped around Moore and Donovan. He was smiling. Two words were embroidered on his shirt: “Go away.”

‘They feel like parents’

Zach had known Moore and Donovan for less than two weeks when he agreed to move with them to Virginia. It was May 2018. He was orphaned, homeless and on probation.

His adoptive mother, who had raised him and his older brother since they were babies, had died unexpectedly of pneumonia in November 2017. Three months later, on Valentine’s Day, Nikolas Cruz opened fire inside Marjory Stoneman Douglas High, killing three staff members and 14 students — people Zach had known growing up.

After Zach was interviewed by detectives for hours, he hid out from news cameras for days. In March, he took his skateboard to the Stoneman Douglas campus, trying to grapple with what his brother had done there. He was arrested for trespassing.

Zach spent 10 days in jail, much of it on suicide watch, according to his public defender at the time. He was then placed on probation and sent back to the home of a former neighbor he had been living with since his mother’s death. By May, the neighbor had kicked him out and called police on him for driving a car without a license.

Prosecutors said Zachary Cruz, brother of convicted Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz, was heard admiring his brother’s popularity during jailhouse visits. (Video: Reuters)

But this time when Zach was released from police custody, he was told there were three people who wanted to meet him: Moore, Donovan, and their adopted 14-year-old son. They took Zach to the penthouse of the oceanfront hotel where they were staying, bought him clothes from the hotel gift shop and told him they were there to help.

Soon, Zach was back in front of the judge overseeing his probation.

Two of the couple’s employees testified that they would be providing Zach with an apartment of his own, online schooling, weekly counseling and a $13 an hour job doing maintenance work.

“You need to just take this moment and appreciate what they are offering you,” the judge, Melinda Kirsch Brown, told Zach, granting him permission to move.

Donovan and Moore, whose records include convictions for grand larceny, forgery and fraudulent checks, did not take the stand. A recording of the hearing shows no one asking who they were or why they were getting involved. No one brought up the media coverage of the allegations against their multimillion dollar business, Nexus Services.

For the past seven years, advocacy groups and state attorneys general have accused Nexus of exploiting undocumented immigrants by bailing them out of detention, then requiring them to pay exorbitant fees to maintain their freedom. Lawsuits and investigations against the company have mounted from nearly a dozen states and federal agencies, including the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. In some cases, the lawsuits were dismissed or are still pending. In others, Nexus has been ordered to pay millions in damages.

Donovan and Moore maintain that they are not exploiting anyone. In Donovan’s book, “Not Free America: What Your Government Doesn’t Want You To Know,” he says the investigations are simply retaliation for “our unapologetic service to God’s flock.”

This company is making millions from America’s broken immigration system

Donovan describes himself as the pastor of First Christian Church Universalist in Harrisonburg, Va. The church rarely meets in person, but its website advertises the podcast, book and businesses of “Rev. Mike.”

As Nexus made a name for itself, Donovan has consistently been the public face of the company, promoting a mix of social justice advocacy and anti-government tirades. Moore, whom Donovan said he married in 2016, deals with the company’s finances and tends to their side projects, including a store selling video games and Disney collectibles.

They are known for their generosity — providing their employees and friends with homes and vacations — and for their vindictiveness — filing lawsuits, launching social media attacks and admitting to hiring paid protesters to target those they perceive to be their enemies.

Nexus has been sued repeatedly by employees who say they were never paid and clients who say they were scammed. At the same time, the company has filed high-profile lawsuits of its own, typically in cases already in the news. It sued the Trump administration for separating families at the border and sued the police chief of Charlottesville for failing to prevent violence at the 2017 “Unite the Right” rally.

It has also spun off a multitude of other ventures. At various times, the company has run “Nexus Investigations & Security,” “Homes by Nexus,” “Nexus Health Inc.” and “Entertainment by Nexus.”

The connection to Zach led to more lawsuits, more spinoffs and more headlines. Within a year Zach moving to Virginia, Nexus lawyers filed two lawsuits against Broward County officials, saying Zach’s rights had been violated after he was detained for trespassing. With a news conference in front of local and national media in Washington, Nexus launched “We Isolate No-One,” an anti-bullying hotline. The number is now disconnected.

When Zach gave interviews about his new life, as he did with The Washington Post in 2019, he was monitored at all times by Nexus employees, who recorded his interactions with a reporter.

“If I didn’t meet Mike and Richard, I don’t know what would have happened,” Zach said at the time. “They feel like parents to me. … If I left, I wouldn’t find that anywhere else.”

He’d grown up in a house where his mother unplugged his Xbox to save on electricity. In Donovan and Moore’s 4,700 square-foot home in Fishersville, Va., he had his own bedroom and a room just for gaming, with a massive TV and multiple systems to play with their son Sam.

Instead of the maintenance job and high school classes that had been described to his probation judge, Zach joined Donovan and Moore on business trips, sleeping late in luxury hotel rooms. He posed for family photos, celebrated Christmas, and every time he cracked his skateboard trying out a new trick, he was able to buy a new one. The couple called him “our son.”

Zach expressed a desire for a quiet life out of the spotlight. But Donovan and Moore continued to seek it.

In 2021, they began promoting an online streaming platform called “TV Unleashed.” Its centerpiece was “Dog Unleashed,” a new reality show about Dog the Bounty Hunter, Duane Chapman, who had started spending time in Virginia after his wife died in 2019.

Another show involved one of Chapman’s daughters. It featured her, Sam and a group of young activists who associated themselves with Black Lives Matter, protesting outside the headquarters of the Augusta County Sheriff — the same sheriff who had previously investigated Donovan and Moore, and who the couple has been publicly battling with for years through lawsuits and on social media.

The protest show also went to Illinois to picket outside the home of the president of RLI Insurance — the same insurance company that won a $5.7 million lawsuit against Nexus for unpaid bonds. (After losing an appeal, Nexus has yet to pay all it owes.)

Then came advertisements for shows called “Parkland: My Side of the Story” and “Being Zachary Cruz.” One preview showed Zach skateboarding as Donovan gave an impassioned voice-over about him. The show’s logo featured Zach encircled by pictures of the couple.

“There’s no secrets in our household,” Moore is filmed saying in another preview. “A lot of people would say it’s dysfunctional, it’s strange, but so are all the people who live in our house.”

The venture never seemed to fully launch. The website for TV Unleashed remains “under construction.”

Meanwhile, the couple was becoming more involved in a matter that would soon be on TVs everywhere: Nikolas Cruz’s death penalty sentencing trial.

Records of jail calls show that after moving to Virginia, Zach almost never held video visits with his brother without Donovan or Moore present. Eventually, Moore started visiting alone. By 2022, the two were talking almost every day.

Moore sent thousands of dollars to the shooter’s commissary and bought him dress clothes to wear to court. He showed up to watch jury selection with a security guard by his side and gave an interview to the local news. He announced on Facebook that he was going to be called as a witness in the case.

“I never truly understood what it truly meant to hate the sin and love the sinner until now,” Moore wrote.

In almost every call, records show, Cruz wanted to know where Zach was. When, he asked, could he talk to his brother?

‘Where is your money?’

The caller said his name was Zachary Cruz. He was inquiring about the money he was entitled to receive from his mother’s life insurance policy.

“Do you know how they mail out the payment?” the caller asked the insurance company representative, according to police records. He asked that the check be overnighted to him via Fedex.

Two checks were mailed out the next day, Aug. 7, 2019, police records show. One was for $207.17. The other was for $426,553.30.

Police say the caller was not Zach. An FBI investigation, which was later described by the Augusta County Sheriff’s Department in search warrant affidavits, concluded the caller was Timothy Shipe, a vice president at Nexus. Shipe, who was later arrested alongside Donovan and Moore, had been the one to tell a Florida judge in 2018 that he would be personally responsible for providing Zach with a maintenance job.

“The allegations against me are all false and will be disposed of during trial,” Shipe said in a statement. “My only hope is that people will let Zach live his life post-Parkland trial.”

The checks, the search warrant affidavit said, were deposited into a joint checking account belonging to both Zach and Moore. The account had been opened after public defenders learned about the existence of a life insurance policy and disclosed in court how large the payout was expected to be. Police say the day after the inheritance made the news, Donovan called MetLife to ask about the money.

The half that belonged to the shooter would likely be tied up in the lawsuits filed by families of the victims. But Zach was entitled to more than $426,000. Overnight, he had gone from destitute and dependent to having the money to buy a house and a car, or to kick-start his dream of owning his own skate shop.

But four days after the checks were deposited, police records show, someone logged into the shared bank account from Moore and Donovan’s home address and withdrew $300,000. The next day, someone logged into the account from the Nexus Services headquarters, and removed another $100,000.

The first withdrawal, police allege, was used to pay the Internal Revenue Service.

It is unclear if Moore was already aware that he was under scrutiny for not paying payroll taxes. In 2021, he was charged with tax fraud by the Justice Department for allegedly failing to pay the IRS more than $1.5 million. He has pleaded not guilty.

Court filings show that in recent years, Nexus has suffered major drops in revenue, has been ordered to pay millions from lawsuits and class-action settlements and has endured what their lawyers described as “crippling, multimillion dollar expenses that were not anticipated.”

The $100,000 that remained from Zach’s money, the search warrant affidavit states, went to credit card bills and car payments linked to a BMW and a Ferrari.

By January 2021, someone had learned about the transactions. This person, whom law enforcement has not named, alerted Shenandoah Valley Social Services, which investigates allegations of abuse of children and vulnerable adults in the community.

According to a petition filed by the agency and obtained by The Post, the tipster reported that Zach was not aware that his money had been spent. The person claimed that Zach had mental health challenges, was not able to manage his own finances and also referred to him as “mentally retarded,” a term widely considered to be a slur toward people with developmental and learning disabilities. Moore and Donovan later expressed outrage about the offensive term and said Zach is completely competent.

Under Virginia law, when an Adult Protective Services unit receives a tip, it is required to begin an investigation within 24 hours, and to attempt to make face-to-face contact with the potential victim within seven days.

“The law places financial exploitation in the same category of concerns as physical abuse or neglect,” said Stephen Strosnider, an attorney for the agency who declined to comment on the specifics of Zach’s case.

But the petition states that when a social worker tried to visit Zach at Donovan and Moore’s home, she was stopped by one of the armed guards the couple pays to monitor their property. The social worker was not allowed into the house, the petition stated.

She left a letter explaining why she wanted to speak to Zach.

Strosnider said it is rare for Shenandoah social workers to be denied access to a potential victim of exploitation.

The agency took the matter to a judge, explaining in its petition that the social worker was coordinating with an FBI investigator. The judge granted the request, writing that there was good cause to interview Zach.

In response, Donovan and Moore filed a lawsuit against the social worker.

They claimed she was involved in a conspiracy against them, along with what they acknowledged was an unlikely group of co-defendants. They sued the FBI agent, whom they said had gone “rogue.” They sued one of their former employees, whom Moore has referred to as a “stalker,” alleging he was involved. They sued Chapman, a.k.a. Dog the Bounty Hunter, whom they accused of being the tipster.

The lawsuit, which garnered tabloid headlines, claimed Chapman was exacting revenge for their decision to cancel “Dog Unleashed.”

“Zachary Cruz is not the only person that Donovan and Moore have purportedly taken advantage of,” Chapman said in a statement. “My family has fallen prey in various ways to their scams as well.”

The suit also claimed Virginia was trying to place Zach into a conservatorship, “much like the one Brittany Spears has been forced to endure, where he would have no control over his life.” (The suit misspelled Spears’s first name, Britney.)

Through it all, Zach shared little with the outside world besides videos of himself at the skate park.

Lawyer Mario Williams was hired by Donovan and Moore to represent both Nexus and Zach. As social services investigated, Williams took Zach aside and asked him if he was comfortable with Donovan and Moore managing his money. Williams said in an interview that he believed Zach was competent to make his own financial decisions. But he had no idea, he said, that the inheritance was already gone.

“Zach did not care at all what they did with the money,” Williams said. “He said the words, ‘I trust them, and they can do what they want.’ ”

In September 2021, Zach was called to testify about the matter in front of a federal grand jury. An excerpt of his testimony included in police records shows he told the prosecutor Moore had given him a lot of money over the years. But when asked if he ever gave permission for Moore and Donovan to use his money to pay the IRS, Zach answered no.

“If the Department of Justice has Zach saying no, I never gave them permission to use the money for that specific thing … that could be a real problem for them,” Williams said.

Though Moore and Donovan were not charged at the time, the scrutiny of the inheritance money did not go away. In April 2022, Florida prosecutors held a video-conference deposition with Zach in preparation for the Parkland sentencing trial. He was required to answer their questions if he was going to testify on his brother’s behalf

The attorneys repeatedly asked Donovan to leave the room. He refused.

“Where is your money?” prosecutor Jeff Marcus asked, referencing the inheritance.

“It’s, like away. Like, I still have, like, money that’s supposed to be coming,” Zach said.

“So do you have the money or is it still supposed to be coming? It’s now over four years later,” Marcus said. “Is it fair to say you have no idea where any money is that you may have inherited?”

Before Zach could say more, his new attorney, who was also representing Moore, interrupted. She wouldn’t allow him to answer questions about the money. She wouldn’t allow him to answer questions about his life in Virginia, or “TV Unleashed,” or Moore and Donovan’s felony records.

When Moore was deposed, the attorney, Amina Matheny-Willard, objected to similar questions.

“Are you making money off of Zach Cruz’s notoriety of being Nikolas Cruz’s brother?” Marcus asked.

Prosecutors took the issue to the judge, arguing that under Florida law, witnesses are required to answer relevant questions during depositions. The judge agreed, issuing an order commanding Moore and Zach to meet with the attorneys again and this time, “answer all questions asked of them.”

It never happened. On Sept. 14, a “statement from Zachary Cruz” was sent to the media announcing Zach would no longer voluntarily testify in the case.

“Broward prosecutors partnered with a racist Virginia Sheriff and a corrupt prosecutor to attempt to arrest me, search my home, and subject me to a conservatorship,” the statement read.

It was filled with accusations of witness tampering and a warning to Broward County officials. When his brother’s case was over, Zach’s statement promised, he’d be filing a lawsuit.

On a sunny afternoon two weeks before the police raid on his house and three weeks before the verdict in his brother’s case, Zach was in the place he’d always rather be: a local skate park.

Approached by The Washington Post reporter who’d interviewed him extensively in 2019, he said he did not know that she had been trying to reach him for months through Donovan and Moore.

There was a lot he wanted to say, he explained. He knew about the statement that had been put out, which he said he gave input on, but Donovan wrote.

“I’m not good with speeches or nothing like that,” Zach said.

He was on his way to buy another new skateboard, after an off-balance landing had left a jagged crack between his wheels. He’d been spending nearly all of his time here, perfecting his tricks, one aspect of his life that was his to control. But lately, he said, even skating had been hard to concentrate on. Sometimes he just sat in his car, watching his brother’s trial unfold. He read the news coverage. He thought about what people say to him when they learn who his brother is.

“As many times as your brother shot those people, that’s how many times he deserves to get shot,” he said a friend at the skate park had told him.

Everyone seemed to be paying attention again, reliving the horrific thing his brother had done. But for the past 4½ years, Zach had never stopped reliving it.

In 2019, Zach Cruz, brother of Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz, gave an interview to The Washington Post about turning to skateboarding as an escape. (Video: Whitney Leaming/TWP)

He said he sometimes went weeks without sleeping. He broke his skateboards on purpose. One night in 2020, he broke a window and didn’t know why. He ended up hospitalized for his mental health, he said.

“I always think, what did that to me?” he said. “And I think it’s just thinking of my brother, every day.”

He knew that his brother wanted to talk to him more often. He knew the attorneys had wanted him to testify. He just didn’t know what he wanted to do.

“It sounds bad to say, but I don’t think that he deserves a chance, sometimes,” Zach said about his brother. “That’s the thing with me. Sometimes I just don’t know if I’m supporting the right side.”

All the while, he said, Moore and Donovan have been guiding him.

When asked what had happened to his inheritance money, he answered, “Really it’s like Richard is helping me with all of that. I’ve never even asked Richard about the stuff, the plans we’ve already made. We already talked about it but, I feel like I forgot already. That type of information doesn’t stick well with me. He can tell me, ‘Oh we are going to do this, this, this, this, and this.’ And I’ll barely remember like half of the list.”

He shifted his broken skateboard. He didn’t look like the four-year-old Post photograph that had been sent to the media along with his statement.

He now had a multiple face tattoos, including a green ribbon beneath his left eye, a symbol of mental health awareness. Tattooed across his knuckles were the words ‘LOST SOUL.’

Zach shared his phone number. He wanted to get going to the skate shop. But then he thought of something else he wanted to say.

“Another thing I can tell you is, that show — ‘Being Zach Cruz’ — nothing is happening with that. I’m not doing that,” he said.

“I don’t want to be on TV … especially because I don’t think things are fairly represented. I just feel like things feel scripted when there’s cameras and stuff,” he said.

He searched for the right words.

“I don’t know, it’s hard. I feel like there’s more to explain, but I don’t know,” he said. “I don’t want to make a scene, that’s really it. I’m gonna cut it at that. I don’t want to make a scene.”

He drove off. Then he texted Donovan.

‘Saving people like myself’

The jury’s verdict had been delivered, but the sentencing for Nikolas Cruz was not over. Under Florida law, the families and survivors were allowed to return to the courtroom a final time. One by one this week, they stepped up to a podium, looked the shooter in the eye and told him just how much he had taken from them. They spoke of the goodbyes they would never get to say and the feelings of safety they would never get back. They called him a remorseless monster. A domestic terrorist. Pure evil.

Their anguish was streamed live on YouTube.

As they spoke on Tuesday, attorneys in Virginia were working on a new lawsuit against Augusta County Sheriff Donald Smith, for the raid on Donovan and Moore’s home. Also named in the suit: the social worker who tried to check on Zach. (The sheriff’s department and the social services agency declined to comment.)

The lawsuit, filed in Zach’s name Wednesday, alleged misconduct, corruption and racism. It was accompanied by a 10-page “sworn affidavit of Zachary Paul Cruz.” It stated that Zach had been present when Shipe asked for his inheritance check to be overnighted to him.

“I told Mike I wanted to give the money to Nexus, and that I wanted to support a company that was saving people like myself,” the affidavit said. “Richard and Mike have NEVER taken any money from my account that I did not authorize.”

Zach, the sworn statement said, has received more than $460,000 from Moore and Donovan since he moved to Virginia for “trips, cars, skating and other expenses.”

“To be clear,” the affidavit from Zach concluded, “Richard and Mike have cared for me when no one else cared.”

In an email, Donovan said the decision to sue the sheriff was Zach’s. A Nexus attorney also forwarded a statement, attributed to Zach, which largely repeated the assertions in the lawsuit.

But when the attorney checked to see if Zach could do an interview Tuesday afternoon, she was told he was busy.

Another survivor was taking the stand in Florida, and Zach was watching.

Story editing by Lynda Robinson, photo editing by Mark Miller, copy editing by Thomas Heleba and Jordan Melendrez, design by Michael Domine. Researcher Alice Crites contributed to this report.



Read original article here

Parkland shooter’s victims face him in court once more before he’s sentenced to life in prison



CNN
 — 

Anguished survivors of the Parkland school shooting and grieving relatives of victims are facing the gunman in court before he’s sentenced to life in prison, testifying Tuesday about the loved ones and feelings of security he stole from them, and expressing anger over a jury’s decision not to recommend he be put to death.

“You don’t know me, but you tried to kill me,” teacher Stacey Lippel told Nikolas Cruz, who attended court in a red prison jumpsuit, thick eyeglasses and a medical mask. “The person I was at 2:20 (p.m.) on Wednesday, February 14, 2018, is not the same one who stands here today. I am broken and altered, and I will never look at the world the same way again.”

Many of those who took the stand spoke directly to Cruz, including the widow of victim Christopher Hixon, who told the gunman he did not get the justice he deserved: “You were given a gift – a gift of grace and mercy,” Debra Hixon said, “something you did not show to any of your victims.”

Follow live updates: Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz to be formally sentenced

After a monthslong trial to decide if Cruz should get the death penalty, a jury recommended he serve a life sentence without the possibility of parole for the shooting at a South Florida high school in which 17 people were killed, sparing his life after his defense attorneys argued he was a disturbed, mentally ill person.

Broward County Circuit Judge Elizabeth Scherer must abide by the jury’s recommendation – three jurors voted against a death sentence, which in Florida must be unanimous – when she sentences Cruz, 24, who pleaded guilty last year to 17 counts of murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the deadliest mass shooting at an American high school, even as the scourge of gun violence on US campuses continues.

She is expected to issue a formal sentence Wednesday.

David Robinovitz, the grandfather of 14-year-old Alyssa Alhadeff, referred Tuesday to Cruz not by his name but as “Parkland murderer,” saying while the shooter “won for now,” one day he will die.

“At that time, Parkland murderer, it is my hope that you go somewhere to meet your maker,” Robinovitz said. “And, Parkland murderer, I hope your maker sends you directly to hell to burn for the rest of your eternity.”

The older sister of slain 14-year-old Alaina Petty expressed her disappointment with the outcome of the court case that followed the attack.

“He chose to turn to violence,” Meghan Petty said, “and is now being protected from the same punishment he needlessly inflicted on my sister because he’s too scared to receive what he exuberantly dished out.”

Many of the Parkland families already had testified over several days this summer as prosecutors closed their case for the death penalty, describing the depth of the loss they had suffered. But those statements, according to the father of 14-year-old victim Jaime Guttenberg, who was among 14 students killed, did not include everything the families wanted to say because they had to be vetted by attorneys on both sides.

“It wasn’t the extent of how we feel,” Fred Guttenberg told CNN last month after the jury’s decision. “At the sentencing hearing, we will get to say whatever we want, including discussing how we feel now about this verdict.”

On Tuesday, the father of victim Alex Schachter expressed his displeasure with the earlier restrictions put on the families, calling them “very upsetting.”

“We were prohibited from talking about the murderer, the crime and the punishment that he deserves,” Max Schachter said, “(that) we wanted that creature to receive.”

Others went further, attacking not only the outcome of the trial but also the shooter’s appointed public defenders. Eventually, public defender Melisa McNeill objected, reminding the court all defendants are afforded the right to legal representation in the US justice system.

“Attacking defense counsel, attacking the judicial system and attacking the jurors is not permissible,” she said, adding it sends a “message to the community” that if you sit on a jury and render a verdict others don’t agree with, “that you will be chastised and degraded.”

Prosecutors responded by noting victims’ families had been limited on what they could say earlier in the trial, accusing the defense of trying to “curtail” their rights to speak – something McNeill disagreed with.

This second round of victim impact testimony will happen over two days, the Broward County State Attorney’s Office confirmed to CNN in a statement ahead of the hearing. It’s unclear how many of them or victims’ loved ones will take the stand, but no time limits are being imposed, and some people may testify via video conference.

Victim impact statements this week do not need to be shown to the lawyers in advance, the state attorney’s office said.

Because of his plea, Cruz skipped the guilt phase of his trial and instead moved directly to the sentencing phase, in which prosecutors sought a death sentence while Cruz’s appointed public defenders lobbied for life without parole.

To make their decisions, jurors heard prosecutors and defense attorneys argue for several months over aggravating factors and mitigating circumstances – reasons Cruz should or should not be executed.

Prosecutors pointed to seven aggravating factors, including that the killings were especially heinous, atrocious or cruel, as well as cold, calculated and premeditated, backing their case with evidence the gunman spent months meticulously planning the shooting, modifying his AR-15 to improve his marksmanship and accumulating ammunition.

Prosecutors also presented Cruz’s online search history showing how he sought information about past mass shootings, as well as comments he left on YouTube, sharing his express desire to perpetrate a mass killing.

“What one writes,” lead prosecutor Michael Satz said during closing arguments, “what one says, is a window to someone’s soul.”

But defense attorneys said their client should be sentenced to life instead, pointing to a lifetime of struggles that began before he was even born: His biological mother, they said, used drugs and alcohol while pregnant with Cruz, causing a slew of mental and intellectual deficits that stemmed from fetal alcohol spectrum disorder.

Despite his issues – and the educators and school counselors who were concerned about his behavior and poor academic performance – Cruz never got adequate or appropriate intervention, defense attorneys argued. This was in part due to his late adoptive mother who, defense attorney McNeill said, “never truly appreciated” what was wrong with him.

“Sometimes,” McNeill said in her own closing argument, “the people who deserve the least amount of compassion and grace and remorse are the ones who should get it.”

In rendering their decision, the jury unanimously agreed the state had proven the aggravating factors beyond a reasonable doubt – and they were sufficient to warrant a possible death sentence.

Ultimately, however, the jurors did not unanimously agree the aggravating factors outweighed the mitigating circumstances, resulting in a recommendation for life in prison and not death.

Three jurors voted against recommending the death sentence, jury foreman Benjamin Thomas told CNN affiliate WFOR – a decision he disagreed with, noting: “I don’t like how it turned out, but … that’s how the jury system works.”

One of the jurors was a “hard ‘no,’” who couldn’t vote for death because she “didn’t believe, because he was mentally ill, he should get the death penalty,” Thomas said. Two more jurors joined her.

The woman was “not moving” from her stance, juror Melody Vanoy told CNN. “Whether we took 10 hours or five days” to deliberate, “she didn’t feel she was going to be moved either way.”

Vanoy herself voted for life, telling CNN she was persuaded because she “felt that the system failed” Cruz repeatedly throughout his life.

Regardless, the outcome did little for the families who hoped to see Cruz sentenced to death and who, in the hours after the jury’s verdict was read, saw their disappointment turn to anger and confusion as they grappled with the decision.

“I’m disgusted with those jurors,” said Ilan Alhadeff, the father of student victim Alyssa Alhadeff. “I’m disgusted with the system, that you can allow 17 dead and 17 others shot and wounded, and not get the death penalty. What do we have the death penalty for?”

“This shooter did not deserve compassion,” Tony Montalto, father of slain 14-year-old Gina Montalto, said outside the courtroom after the jury’s findings were read.

“Did he show the compassion to Gina when he put the weapon against her chest and chose to pull that trigger, or any of the other three times that he shot her? Was that compassionate?”

Not all the victims relatives felt that way. Before the end of the trial, Robert Schentrup, the brother of victim Carmen Schentrup, told CNN he was against the death penalty – in Cruz’s case and all others.

“Logically,” he said, “it doesn’t follow for me that we say, ‘Murdering someone is this horrible, heinous, awful, terrible thing, and in order to prove that point, we’re going to do it to someone else.’”

Read original article here

The Ultimate News Site